Discover this place
Nestled in the picturesque Cherry Grove, "Sand Castle" stands out as a beacon for both locals and visitors seeking an unforgettable dining experience. With its stunning oceanfront views and a commitment to culinary excellence, this restaurant has quickly become a favorite on Fire Island. Diners rave about the rotating menu, which offers an impressive array of delectable options, including gluten-free and vegan choices, ensuring something for everyone. Patrons like Eduardo Viezca praise the above-average food and the kind wait staff, while Erika Lorshbough highlights the sweet, attentive service, adding to the vibrant atmosphere. The engaging cocktail menu features delightful martinis like the Beach Bum and Ocean Breeze, and guests can indulge in decadent desserts like the warm lava cake and mini cannolis. Special mentions go to the unique dishes, such as the mushroom calamari, and the innovative vegan burgers, which elevate the beach dining experience. The friendly and hilarious bar crew adds a lively touch, making every visit memorable. With genuine hospitality and a picturesque setting, "Sand Castle" has captured the hearts—and appetites—of many. It’s not just a meal; it’s a celebration of the season, best enjoyed with friends, good food, and the sound of the waves in the background.Photos
Amenities & More
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Dine-in
- Delivery
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great cocktails
- Serves local specialty
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Dining options
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
- Table service
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Romantic
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
What's on the menu
Reviews for Sand Castle
Review highlights
Based on 168 reviewsSand Castle is widely praised for its scenic oceanfront location and inviting atmosphere, offering diners picturesque views that enhance the overall experience. Guests consistently highlight the attentive and friendly service, often noting staff’s exceptional care and engaging hospitality. The menu is frequently commended for its variety and quality, featuring a rotating selection that includes appealing gluten-free and vegan options, which stand out amid typical beach fare. The restaurant’s creative and well-presented dishes, combined with a vibrant bar scene offering innovative cocktails, contribute to its reputation as a standout destination on Fire Island. Overall, feedback reflects a strong appreciation for both the setting and the consistently satisfying dining experience.
Above average food, nice views of the water and kind wait staff. What else could you ask for?
The Sand Castle is one of the great Fire Island bars/restaurants. The view is gorgeous - true oceanfront dining - and the staff are sweet and fun and attentive. The menu tends to rotate and is always amazing! Generally lots of gluten free and vegan options which is especially nice for an island/beach environment, which is otherwise a bit heavy with fried food, pizza, and beach snacks. It’s also a fun cash bar with a good amount of outside seating at the rail or to take drinks away for a hot beach day.
One of our favorite places in fire island. Always good food and great service. Our sever Brandon really took care of us.
This is the perfect way to start your Sunday. Samuel and bar crew are hilarious and oooh we had the rocket reach and boy did it send us to the moon!!! Loved it Andrew and John in the restaurant were phenomenal. The mezcal paper planes soared to new nights. Not your grandmas paper planes!! The mushroom calamari is to die for and the burgers (vegan and poppers burger) are incredible. We had a beautiful bottle of wine with the best views on fire island, we even spotted a pod of whales in the ocean 10/10
This is one of those places that will super surprise you . The restaurant is super cute. Comfortable and nice looking. Staff , OMG ...starting from the host and our waiter ,they were beyond brilliant. Food was perfect, Tasty and brilliant presentation. All 5 for this place .
Phenomenal service and Amazing Food. If your in the Grove you HAVE to go to sand castle for dinner. Drinks are strong but not too strong and the food was absolutely perfect. I had the salmon and my buddy got the halibut; freshest fish I’ve ever had. Another friend got a burger and he said it was one of the best he’d ever had.
We ate here twice in August 2024, and both times impressed me. I say the date because it seems Fire Island places are always changing teams and managers, so they do have issues with consistency. Crab bisque, snapper, mollusks, bbq burnt ends, short ribs with gnocchi, Caesar salad—all very fresh and well prepared in our visits. Caesar was marked endive Caesar, but no endive appeared. Salad was still good, maybe just change the menu? Mollusks are usually a good choice in NY and here is no exception: fresh and lovely wine sauce. I think toasting the bread with a gas grill adds a gassy char that’s not quite right. But that’s nitpicking. Yes, it’s every bit as expensive as Manhattan, so not a budget choice at all. But nothing on Fire Island really is.
I loved every single thing about our dinner. Everyone was friendly & kind very helpful. Food was fabulous. I can't say enough about this place.
Write a review
Share your experience with the community. Your honest feedback helps others find great places.
Quick info
Location
Own this business?
Claim this listing to update info, respond to reviews and reach more customers.
Claim listingMore places in New York
Discover more places like this
Browse thousands of bars, restaurants, cafés and more — wherever you go.